Committee for Skeptical Inquiry

[Barry Karr <SkeptInq@AOL.COM>]

            Bad Science, Bad Fiction

In Michael Crichton's work, the two are intimately connected.

Chris Mooney; January 18, 2005

Michael Crichton's latest book, State of Fear, is a novel in name only. More accurately described, it's a work of thinly disguised political commentary, in which a wildly implausible plot--eco-terrorists supplant Al Qaeda as the leading global menace, unveiling dastardly weather modification schemes to convince the public of a nonexistent global warming threat--serves as an excuse for a string of Socratic-style dialogues about climate science. Since Crichton's characters repeatedly find themselves jetting across the globe to stop the latest eco-terrorist menace (blowing off parts of Antarctica, unleashing a tsunami, and so on), they have plenty of time in transit to question the reality of human caused global warming. The plot contrivance of a pending climate change lawsuit--abandoned once its proponents realize they don't have a case--provides yet another didactic opportunity for the author. When the legal team cross-examines one of our heroes about climate science, Crichton seizes the chance to insert temperature trend diagrams and copious footnotes into the text.

To Read More of this Column Visit:

 www.csicop.org  and http://www.csicop.org/doubtandabout/crichton/

To Read More Articles by Chris Mooney Visit: http://www.csicop.org/doubtandabout/

http://www.chriscmooney.com/

Please do not reply to back to the listserv.  Any list questions should be addressed to: skeptinq@aol.com